Direct Care Crisis Deepens: State Programs Face Cuts as National Workforce Shortage Grows

In a move that could signal broader changes across the country, Idaho's Department of Health and Welfare is seeking federal approval to end its Medicaid-funded family caregiver program by January 31, 2025. The program, which currently allows family members to receive payment for providing care to relatives with disabilities, has seen its enrollment nearly double since 2023, raising concerns about sustainability and oversight.

Idaho Program Changes Signal Potential National Shifts

The state reports that enrollment has grown to 1,178 children, with projections indicating further expansion to 1,413 children by year's end. This growth has pushed program costs to nearly $8 million in 2024, significantly exceeding the fiscal year 2025 budget of $4.2 million. Idaho's Health and Welfare Director Alex Adams cited both financial concerns and program integrity issues in the decision to seek early termination.

While acknowledging that many families utilize the program appropriately and face genuine difficulties finding direct care workers, particularly in rural areas, state officials express concern about program abuse. The department plans to implement enhanced oversight measures for the program's remaining duration, including quarterly reviews and extended processing times for new requests.

National Crisis Reveals Deep Challenges in Care Workforce

These developments in Idaho come against the backdrop of a national direct care workforce crisis, detailed in a recent Commonwealth Fund report. The report reveals that the United States currently relies on 4.8 million direct care workers to provide essential services to over 12 million people across home care, residential facilities, and nursing homes. Despite their crucial role, these workers face significant economic challenges, with a median hourly wage of just $15.43 and annual earnings of $23,688.

The economic reality for direct care workers is stark: 39% live in or near poverty, and 46% depend on public assistance programs to make ends meet. These conditions contribute to ongoing recruitment and retention challenges, even as the sector faces unprecedented growth demands. Projections indicate the need to fill 9.3 million direct care positions by 2031, including both new jobs and replacements for departing workers.

States across the country have attempted to address these challenges through various initiatives, particularly using enhanced federal funding provided during the pandemic. Forty-eight states increased base payments for direct care workers, and 41 implemented incentive payment programs. However, as pandemic-era funding expires, maintaining even these modest improvements has become increasingly difficult.

The Commonwealth Fund's analysis suggests that addressing the direct care workforce crisis will require coordinated action at both state and federal levels. States are working to standardize training requirements and improve recruitment strategies, but they face significant challenges in building the necessary infrastructure for long-term success. The need for multilingual training materials and support systems for family caregivers remains particularly acute.

For Idaho residents affected by the proposed program termination, a public comment period opened on November 5, 2024, through Townhall Idaho. The state plans to submit its proposal to the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services in early December, ahead of the 2025 legislative session beginning January 6.

The department has committed to working with affected families to identify alternative care options, particularly for those in rural areas where finding direct care workers proves especially challenging. However, this transition comes at a time when the broader direct care workforce shows no signs of stabilizing, raising questions about the long-term viability of current care delivery models across the country.

As states grapple with these challenges, the need for sustainable solutions becomes increasingly urgent. The convergence of program sustainability concerns and workforce shortages suggests that the direct care crisis may require fundamental reforms to ensure consistent, quality care remains available to those who need it most.

Too busy to keep up with all the latest I/DD news and developments? Join our community of parents, caregivers, and professionals who rely on our free weekly newsletter to stay informed.

No spam, just essential news and updates. Unsubscribe anytime.